Realizing change through monitoring, reporting, and fact-finding: B’Tselem’s work regarding Operation Cast Lead
Jessica Montell · 28 April 2014
Archive note, written 27 October 2026. This page was rebuilt at its original address from PHAP's archived copy of this note (Internet Archive, 19 September 2014).
B'Tselem was founded as an information center, out of a perhaps naïve belief in the power of information. If people knew what was happening a few miles away, where the Israeli military maintained its occupation of the Palestinian population, the problems of violence and oppression would be solved – or so we hoped. Monitoring, reporting and fact-finding (MRF) were the primary tasks of the organization: taking testimonies from victims and eye-witnesses to human rights violations, cross-checking this information with other sources and producing comprehensive reports that place these violations in their broader legal context.
That was 25 years ago. Fairly quickly we came to understand that ignorance regarding the human rights violations is not the primary problem. Even when presented with clear evidence regarding human rights violations, people found ways to explain, and deny and justify – a phenomenon studied by criminologist Stanly Cohen, one of B'Tselem's founders, in his book States of Denial.1 More and more documentation of the violations themselves was not going to overcome these mechanisms of rationalization.
Over the years, we developed new strategies to advance human rights: conducting domestic and international advocacy, promoting criminal accountability, and using new media tools to mobilize the public. Yet MRF remains the backbone of B'Tselem's work – it is the necessary first step of any strategy to make change.
There are probably more journalists in Israel-Palestine than in any other conflict zone on earth. With the development of the internet, we all have access to more information than ever before. But an abundance of information is not necessarily helpful, if that information is unreliable. In fact, much of the information regarding human rights produced in our context is manipulated to advance the agenda of one side or the other. For this reason, B'Tselem relies solely on its own documentation or the work of trusted sources.
Our work regarding Operation Cast Lead illustrates this quite clearly. The suffering caused in Israel's large-scale military operation in the Gaza Strip in December 2008 – January 2009 was clear: hundreds of people killed, thousands injured, and massive destruction of homes, infrastructure, and other property. Addressing the suffering, however, required accurate data in order to analyze the situation. How many of those killed were civilians and how many took an active part in hostilities? Were civilian installations willfully targeted or damaged in the course of legitimate military operations? Were civilian facilities used by armed Palestinian groups, making them legitimate targets? Palestinians accused Israel of massacring innocent civilians. Israelis responded that the armed Palestinian groups had used their own civilians as human shields, forcing Israel to conduct the operation in densely populated civilian areas where civilians would be endangered. How should these conflicting claims be evaluated?
B'Tselem collected information from first-person sources on the 1 391 Palestinians killed by Israeli security forces in the Gaza Strip between 27 December 2008 and 18 January 2009. In addition to categorizing the casualties according to whether or not they took part in hostilities, an investigation was conducted into the circumstances of all the civilian deaths in order to render a legal judgment about Israeli military conduct.
B'Tselem also collected similar information regarding the nine Israelis killed by Palestinians during this same period. In this case, the facts were not in dispute: it is clear that three of those killed were civilians, killed in a willful targeting of civilians by Palestinian armed groups.
After months of intense documentation, we were able to conclude that the Palestinians killed in the Gaza Strip during the operation included at least 759 civilians who took no part in the hostilities, 318 of them children. Over 5 300 Palestinians were wounded, more than 350 seriously. Israeli forces destroyed over 3 500 homes, leaving approximately 20 000 persons homeless. The Israeli military also struck industrial and agricultural sites and electricity, sanitation, and water facilities.
B'Tselem's research raised grave suspicions that the Israeli military violated its legal obligations in its conduct during this operation. There are compelling allegations of excessive force, use of indiscriminate weapons, obstruction of ambulances and directing attacks at civilian rather than military targets. Some Palestinian civilians were killed when the military fired mortar shells, a weapon that cannot be aimed accurately, into densely populated areas. Others were killed and horribly injured by white phosphorus shells. Children and adults were forced to serve as human shields, made to walk in front of soldiers and sent first into potentially-mined buildings. The military apparently targeted civilian buildings, like government ministries and the parliament building, although there is no indication they had any military function. These are only some of the very troubling issues raised.
This fact-finding formed the basis of all of our advocacy and public education activities intended to promote accountability for the individual cases, as well as systemic changes to promote accountability and ensure protection for civilians. Given the highly-charged context of our work, and the politicized efforts to discredit the work of groups like B'Tselem, our work would not be possible without the strong base of accurate, reliable information.
About the author
Jessica Montell is Executive Director of B'Tselem: the Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories.
Notes
1 Cohen, Stanley (2001), States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and Suffering, Polity Press.
Topics: Monitoring, reporting, and fact-finding